Question by Angie: Will medicaid pay for alcohol rehab in Utah?
If you had a brother, sister, son, or daughter that needs help. Would you do anything you could to help them? This is a disease!

Best answer:

Answer by raysny
No. Although alcoholism is considered a disease by some, it is treated as a behavior by the government.

http://askjan.org/media/alcohol.html#ADA

Most rehabs are 12step-based, based on AA. Rehabs have a slightly better success rate than Alcoholics Anonymous which is estimated to be about 5%, the same as no treatment at all. People who fail in AA and 12step facilitation tend to fall harder than those who were not exposed to 12step treatment, which teaches people they are powerless to do anything about their addiction, that even God cannot cure alcoholism, only grant a daily reprieve from the desire to drink.

Dr. Brandsma found that A.A. increased the rate of binge drinking, and
Dr. Ditman found that A.A. increased the rate of rearrests for public drunkenness, and
Dr. Walsh found that “free A.A.” made later hospitalization more expensive, and
Doctors Orford and Edwards found that having a doctor talk to the patient for just one hour was just as effective as a whole year of A.A.-based treatment.
Dr. George E. Vaillant, the A.A. Trustee, found that A.A. treatment was completely ineffective, and raised the death rate in alcoholics. No other way of treating alcoholics produced such a high death rate as did Alcoholics Anonymous.
http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-letters85.html

What works? A summary of alcohol treatment research:
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

“About 75 percent of persons who recover from alcohol dependence do so without seeking any kind of help, including specialty alcohol (rehab) programs and AA. Only 13 percent of people with alcohol dependence ever receive specialty alcohol treatment.”
Alcoholism Isn’t What It Used To Be:
http://www.spectrum.niaaa.nih.gov/features/alcoholism.aspx

Give your answer to this question below!

The most known and famous addiction treatment for alcohol rehab centers offers inpatient substance abuse processes to the patients. Such type of treatment helps patients to get strong and efficient to fight the compulsions inpatient treatment for alcohol. Nowadays days, the habits such as alcohol, drug, cocaine, heroin, etc are rapidly growing in adolescent and in young adults across the country. Hence, parents and friends concerned about the patients contact immediately the rehab centers for various treatments such as alcohol rehab center, drug rehab, heroin addiction treatment centers, etc.

Thus, alcohol treatment provided to various patients by the rehab has found inpatient treatment for substance abuse as the most effective solutions. The organizations involved in non-profitable medical care are ones helping the rehab centers to provide various types of efficient treatments to cure all types of obsessions through inpatient procedures and methods. Earlier, drug cases used to be found in abundance and residential drug rehab centers provided great treatment by following the procedure for residential drug treatment programs. Moreover, substance abuse treatments are considered as the effective inpatient treatment for substance abuse by the residential drug treatment centers.

Patients always avoid and get disturb by the frequent visit to the rehab centers when following the inpatient programs. The consultations make sure that the disturbance and disorders should not raise the depression in the mind of patients. Thus, inpatient substance abuse programs help the drug addicts to cure themselves by motivating themselves to eliminate the habits from mind itself. With the help of such treatments patients get to an edge where mental condition can be control when the addiction urges at peak.

In such conditions, evidence based medicine do force the urge for addiction for sometime but never substance abuse help to cure the patients even when the group is addicted to drug and other need. In the addiction of drug treatment inpatient, patients have found unbelievable options and quick recoveries through the halfway houses. Today, rehab centers are providing round-the-clock helpline to help addicted patients to avoid the habituated urge.

The inpatient drug rehab centers plans and associates evidence based treatment through best mental therapies. Patients can call the centers to get initial free telephonic conversation where the nature of addiction gets determined. All details concerning to the rise of such bad habits are taken and patient’s mental health is checked. Therefore, always opt for the rehab center for alcohol dependence and drug addiction to expect quick recoveries.

Clinical trial indicates gabapentin is safe and effective for treating alcohol …
Both treatments aim to blunt the pleasure-seeking motivation that helps initiate alcohol dependence. But they are relatively ineffective against the anxiety, depression, sleeplessness and other protracted withdrawal symptoms that help maintain …
Read more on Eureka! Science News

The Truth About Hangover Cures: What Works
The salt will help replace lost electrolytes, and meat contains Vitamin B6, which reduces hangover symptoms. 3. Another drink helps. Although a hangover is very different from alcohol withdrawal, it might produce acute discontinuation syndrome, which a …
Read more on Healthline

Drug Rehab Findlay's New Helpline Provides Help for Drug and Alcohol Addicts
People can reach the helpline at (419) 605-4662 and speak directly with an addiction and recovery specialist who can provide them with reliable information regarding drug and alcohol treatment programs and facilities. Many people are hesitant to enter …
Read more on PR Web (press release)

NIH-funded study finds that gabapentin may treat alcohol dependence
The generic anticonvulsant medication gabapentin shows promise as an effective treatment for alcohol dependence, based on the results of a 150-patient clinical trial of the medication. Conducted by scientists supported by the National Institute on …
Read more on National Institutes of Health (press release)

Suboxone is effective in treatment of addiction
Many families have a member who is suffering from drug dependency. If you are affected, or know someone who is, Suboxone treatment may be a resource for you. This treatment does not take the place of the full course of therapy needed to resolve the …
Read more on Seacoastonline.com

Gabapentin is safe, effective for treating alcohol dependence, study shows
Nov. 4, 2013 — The generic drug gabapentin, which is already widely prescribed for epilepsy and some kinds of pain, appears to be safe and effective in the treatment of alcohol dependence. The finding comes from a 150-patient randomized, …
Read more on Science Daily (press release)

Constitutional challenge launched against federal government on heroin …
The SALOME clinical study has been testing alternative treatments, including prescription heroin, for people with chronic heroin addiction who are not responding to other treatment, like methadone. “This is a safe, effective treatment,” said Scott …
Read more on Straight.com

Modern Treatment Methods Give New Hope to People Struggling With Addiction
Revelations about the complex nature of addiction make it clear: Successful treatment depends upon a comprehensive approach that recognizes all contributing factors. Relapse rates for addiction hover between 40 and 60 percent; however, modern …
Read more on Marketwired (press release)

Question by denveryay: How is it possible to absolutely categorize Alcoholim as a disease and not an illness?
“Disease” is a very loosely defined term in many respects. There are multiple disorders, infenctions, and symptoms that can be typical of a definable disease. Also, a disease must have specific and constant cause(s), which in the case of Alcoholism is the CHOICE to drink ethyl-alcohol. The cause of the “disease” is the recurring and disregarding CHOICE to drink. A choice, however pathological or illogical, doesn’t seem to be appropriate as a cause or a condition of any disease. Despite the negative psychological, physiological, and other results of long-term alcohol abuse, it seems that it shouldn’t be classified as anything more than a treatable mental disorder.

“Illness, although often used to mean disease, can also refer to a person’s perception of their health, regardless of whether they in fact have a disease. A person without any disease may feel unhealthy and believe he has an illness. Another person may feel healthy and believe he does not have an illness even though he may have a disease” – Wikipedia on ‘Disease’

It is true that if some Alcoholics didn’t have a disease to blame for their disorder, they would not be able to stop drinking. It is also true that because of Alcholism-as-a-disease, many people who ABUSE alcohol are led into misperceptions about their drinking habits. In fact, it is only alcohol DEPENDENCE that could possibly even begin to be categorized as a disease.

An individual who is alcohol-dependent exhibits behavior indicitive of addiction. Drink-seeking, withdrawal and tolerance, and psychological malfunction among others are the results and symptoms of addiction. My father and friends have struggled with alchohol and drug addictions and I have seen the both successful and unsuccessful treatments implemented in their lives.

It seems that Alcoholism and drug addictions are psychological disorders that in a vast majority of instances could be cured by a conscious choice (however difficult) to STOP using the cause of the addiction. It has been proven in many instances that an addict can stop using the object of their addiction without any complications, as long as they are commited to quitting.

It seems that diseases should only be those such as Cancer, Diabetes, Hepatitis and the like. People who have these diseases cannot make a choice to simply stop a behavior to ease their pains. Whereas, although undoubtedly difficult, an addict can ease his or her addiction by making a powerful choice to stop using.

By allowing alcoholism to be categorized as a disease, it seems that negative stigma is removed from addicts’ behaviors and people who drink are given an excuse to justify their behavior. Instead of feeling like they’ve let themselves and their families down, they are able to blam their behavior on a cause outside of their control, which is simply not true.

“Neither the U.S. Veterans Administration nor the Social Security Administration makes payments to individuals, whose disabilities stem from substance abuse, including alcoholism.” – From Shoutwire

I am NOT pro- or anti- any of this I am looking for factual objective evidence and ideas that could lead to helping me understand why Alchoholism is given reprieve by its disease classification.

Best answer:

Answer by kentuckyredhead5353
Well about half way through I had a problem and I developed this question. What is the difference with what you were saying in comparison to a cigarette smoker for some it’s the habit and the motion and some get physically sick for the lack of nicotine is it not similar. emotional vs physical and different for different personality types? 🙂 Guess I could read on have a good one:-)
OK I’m finally done now i get it, it’s all in there head so all they have to do is get it out of their head and it will all go away. They just will it away. Take 2 aspirins have a sucker and call me in the morning:-)
oh excuse me revision: update-read the last part. it was taken out as a disease because social security was being drained by leagal alcoholics that the government makes good taxes off of. The only help and recourse for a recovering alcoholic, drug user, vet, is a mental health clinic because why did they drink in the first place. Now uncle sam pays for their drugs and kills them off with a lousy health plan. looks who is on all the class action suits that will never collect anything. Trust me I have done my homework on this subject. I know many vets and low income disabled people. Nothing has changed but the name of the disease.

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!